Wednesday, May 20, 2015

Final Research Paper


Police brutality and police corruption are controversial issues worldwide. There are always many different sides to a story, and some cases involving corruption or brutality make it hard for courts to make decisions. Not all police officers and departments are corrupt but when these incidents take place, they cause mistrust between the public and the police. One corrupt officer can influence the public's trust or mistrust in the whole department. These officers create a bad reputation for their departments and also for their fellow coworkers. Many people also have their own opinions to whether an officer has done their job or has just taken excessive force to another level. Police corruption and police brutality raise concerns in the public and cause the community to doubt their local police departments whose job is to protect the community.
There are many different definitions and examples of police corruption. According to Herman Goldstein, John Dempsey quotes his definition of police corruption in his book, "Introduction to Policing", as "acts involving the misuse of authority by a police officer in a manner designed to produce personal gain for himself or for others" (Dempsey, 2014, pg 227). The definitions of police corruption vary but they are all similar in stating that an officer is corrupt when he or she are using their authority to receive a benefit for doing something. Police corruption is not only a present day issue, it has taken its toll on police departments for years.
There are many incidents throughout the years that police departments have experienced some sort of corruption by an officer or a group of officers. For example in the 1980s and 1990s police departments in Miami, New York and New Orleans experienced corruption and officers in these cities were involved in drug dealing, robberies, batteries and murder and were later on charged.  The "Rampart" scandal was another case of police corruption. In February 2000, more than 70 officers in the Los Angeles Police Department were investigated for committing crimes or covering up beatings and shootings, planting evidence and committing perjury (Dempsey, 2014, p. 230).
Perjury is when officers lie under oath or give false evidence or testimony. As one can clearly see, police corruption takes place all over the place and has been going on for years which makes it a significant topic for many to understand. Dempsey quotes Lawrence W. Sherman, "For as long as there have been police, there has been police corruption" (Dempsey, 2014, pg 230). As one can see from the previous quote, police corruption has been in effect for many years, and is still ongoing. There does not seem to have been many successful efforts made on solving the issue since police have been around protecting communities.
Cases involving police corruption are always in the newspaper because the media is so quick to attack police officers. Dempsey states, "For the past few decades, police misconduct has made headlines far too often" (Dempsey, 2014, 233). Because of all the media attention, officers who are not involved in the corruption are affected as well. The media influences the police as well as the public. The media portrays young African American men as criminals frequently. For example, when a young African American man grasps the media’s attention the media will portray him negatively, using photos related to gang violence or drug and alcohol use, instead of including a photo of him graduating from high school or serving in the military. This may have a major influence on the officer’s opinions and approaches to black Americans. This then causes the public to view their police departments negatively, believing that they are targeting the black community.
 Corruption also affects relationships between the police and the public creating mistrust between the two. A relationship between the public and the police is very important because the police sometimes need the help of the community to solve crimes and without their trust they are not going to get that help. Another problem is within officers themselves, rumors are created because of the lack of information that departments release. Officers then do not know who they can and can not trust.
Police corruption is an extreme issue causing many different problems for police departments and communities. It is an important topic to be discussed and has many cases that will show clear examples of corruption.
            Police corruption has been around since there have been police and there are many cases that prove the negative impact corruption has on the relationship between the police and the community. A significant historical incident that occurred in the year of 1991 was the Rodney King incident. The reason that this incident is so important in history and in my research on police corruption is because Rodney King is like the poster child for police corruption and symbolizes the racial tension that spread throughout America at the time. Rodney King was caught by the Los Angeles Police Department after a high-speed chase. After being caught, the police brutally beat King after pulling him out of his car. Little did the officers know, a man named George Holliday recorded the whole physical altercation on camera. The officers were charged with criminal offenses such as assault with a deadly weapon and excessive use of force by a police officer. Three months of trial took place and the officers were acquitted of all charges, which sparked the 1992 Los Angeles riots. The community started the 1992 Los Angeles riots against the police. As one can see, this incident weakened the relationship between the community and their police department. The community was clearly angered by this incident and felt that they needed to protest against these corrupted officers.
            As stated earlier, there are many definitions of police corruption. The Rodney King incident would fall under the definition by Herman Goldstein as, “acts involving the misuse of authority by a police officer in a manner designed to produce personal gain for himself of others” (Dempsey, 2014, p. 227). Although the officers in the Rodney King incident were not trying to benefit themselves in any way it is still a form of police corruption. The officers are abusing their authority in this case. The riots are a great example of how this form of corruption can have a negative impact on the relationship between the police and the community. The community was clearly rioting against the police for beating this man and walking free.
            There have been many attempts to solve the issue of police corruption to strengthen the relationship between police departments and their communities. Candidates for the police academy are much more educated and trained than they were years ago. Incidents such as the Rodney King beating, changed the way that these candidates and current police officers think of their jobs. Blankstein says, “Today, things are far different and the tape that so tainted the LAPD has a clear legacy in how officers think about their jobs. Police now work in a YouTube world in which cellphones double as cameras, news helicopters transmit close-up footage of unfolding police pursuits, and surveillance cameras capture arrests or shootings” (Blankstein, 2011). One can see the impact that the Rodney King beating had on future policing and that they must always act as if someone is watching them. When the public records the police it also creates a mistrust between the public and the police because now the police does not trust the community they are supposed to be protecting. When incidents are recorded they are most likely used against police. Blankstein says in his article, “The ubiquitous use of cameras by the public has helped serve as a deterrent to police abuse, said Geoff Alpert, a leading expert on police misconduct” (Blankstein, 2011). As one can see, the use of cameras are a nightmare to police officers. Cameras are also changing the way that police officers work and will hopefully have a positive effect on police misconduct. Sarah Glazer says, “In years past, corruption typically took the form of bribery, but today it's often brutality or extortion - with innocent citizens often the victims” (Glazer, 1995). Again another example of police corruption is from the O.J. Simpson case. Former detective, Mark Fuhrman, bragged on television about how he brutally beat two suspects in the case. He also used derogatory language in his interviews such as the “N-word” which enraged people all over America. Glazer says, “But his repeated use of “the N-word” was enough to give new credibility to long-standing complaints by citizens of police misconduct” (Glazer, 1995). His repetition of the “N-word” shows that he thought nothing wrong of the language and was extremely comfortable using it. Again people complained of his actions, which built a barrier between the police department and the people they are paid to protect.
            Incidents of police brutality and police corruption including more recent cases such as the Eric Garner case and the Michael Brown case sparked extreme disaster between the police and the black community mostly. A CBS news poll shows the extremely different racial views on the police. Fred Backus says, “While four in five whites say their local police make them feel mostly safe, that drops to 52 percent among blacks. Forty-three percent of African Americans say the local police make them feel mostly anxious” (Backus, 2014). Many people think that police officers tend to target minority groups which enflames the relationship between the police and these groups.
            Eric Garner was a forty-three year old man who had been arrested over thirty times prior to his final arrest for allegedly selling cigarettes on the street. He had several health issues such as asthma, diabetes and sleep apnea. Garner resisted arrest and Officer Pantaleo put him in a chokehold, which has been proven a deadly use of force from previous cases. Garner passed away after the incident. Again, just like the Rodney King beating the whole entire incident was caught on tape and the officer was not indicted for killing Eric Garner. Police are even more hesitant to trust their people and the people are still uncooperative with the police. Al Baker says, “On the streets of the city, from Tompkinsville to Times Square, many expressed their outrage with some of the last words Mr. Garner uttered before being wrestled to the ground: “This stops today,” people chanted. “I can’t breathe,” others shouted” (Baker, 2014). “This stops today” is referring to police using and abusing their authority and walking free when lives are being taken and families are falling apart. People do not want to support this kind of behavior by the people who are paid to protect them, therefore they are going to riot and bash the police as much as they can. This case has also created tension between police departments and their people.
            Michael Brown, an eighteen year old African American boy, was shot and killed by a police officer two days before he was expected to start college. There were two sides to the story, the police and the public. Again one can see the conflicting arguments that arise between the two, almost as if they are always going against each other. The public says Brown was surrendering with his hands in the air and the police say Brown attacked the police car and reached for the officer’s gun (Shoichet, 2014). The town of Ferguson went insane when Officer Wilson was not indicted. Larry Buchanan says, “The decision not to indict Mr. Wilson set off a wave of anger among those who had gathered outside the Ferguson Police Department. As the night wore on, the situation grew more intense. Buildings were set on fire, and looting was reported in several businesses” (Buchanan, 2014). One can see the extreme events that took place after the jury’s decision. Again, the relationship between the police and the public is extremely damaged and the people are acting out in extreme manners. The police are losing respect from the people when they are set free from charges of murder.
            After the multiple incidents such as the Eric Garner case, the Michael Brown case and even the Trayvon Martin case elected officials are looking for ways to stop police corruption. Police commissioner Bratton speaks of using body cameras on police officers while they are on duty, which will cause them to act in a different manner. When they realize they are being watched and anything that they do wrongfully will be recorded, they are more likely to work by the books. As stated earlier, police must have the mindset that they are always being watched. Others believe that officers need better training and better relations with the community. Andrew Peralta says in the Washington times, ““When you’re training’s all about shooting, handcuffing, the physical part — and not about the verbal part — it can create an imbalance,” he said. An officer also needs training on dealing with community members in nonthreatening ways and better communication skills, he said” (Swarts, 2015). This is a great start for officers to build their relationship with the community.
            As one can see, police corruption creates hostility between the police and the public. The police need the public’s cooperation in order to carry out their jobs successfully. If the corruption continues, there will be no respect for the police and no cooperation from the people. Without respect and cooperation leaves chaos and soon situations will begin to get worse. The police and the public need to work together in order to create a safe and orderly society.
References
Goodman, D., Baker, Al., (2014). “Wave of Protests After Grand Jury Doesn’t Indict Officer in Eric Garner Chokehold Case”. New York Times.
De Pinto, J., Dutton, S., Salvanto, A., Backus,F., (2014). “Michael Brown and Eric Garner: The Police, use of force and race”. CBS News.
Shoichet, C., (2014). “Missouri teen shot by police was two days away from starting college” CNN News.
Buchanan, L., (2014). “What happened in Ferguson?” New York Times
Swarts, P., (2015). “Police need better training and community relations, presidential task force is told”. Washington times.
Dempsey, J.S., Forst, L.S., (2014), An Introduction to Policing, Delmar Cengage Learning. Seventh Edition, pg227-pg234.

Rubin, J., Blankstein, A., Gold, S., (2011), Twenty Years after the beating of Rodney King, the LAPD is a changed operation. Los Angeles Times.

Glazer, S. (1995, November 24). Police corruption: Can brutality and other misconduct be rooted out? CQ Researcher, 5, 1041-1064. Retrieved from http://library.cqpress.com/

Bayley, D., Perito, R., Police Corruption: What past scandals teach about current challenges. United States Institute of Peace. Retrieved from http://permanent.access.gpo.gov/gpo19349/SR%20294.pdf

Journal Entry #10


             This semester in my English 201 course we did a whole lot of writing. One of the things I dislike the most about school is having to write long boring papers the night before they are due. What I learned a lot from this course is not to procrastinate when writing papers, because it’s important to have many drafts before handing in your final paper. Forcing yourself to write drafts is a great way to keep from procrastinating and is very helpful in revising the essay. I believe that my work definitely progressed throughout the semester. I received a better grade on my literary analysis than on my first paper, the literacy narrative. When I received the second grade I was so excited to see that my writing had progressed and I was writing better than before. I feel much more confident in writing papers after this course. The free writing and the journal entries were great practice as well. I learned a lot about paragraph structure and how important it is to focus on only one topic per paragraph. I also learned how to clearly support my thesis throughout the entire essay. I learned how to properly cite quotes and to always explain them afterwards instead of dropping them in the middle of an essay like I used to do. Everything I learned in this class helped me greatly in other classes when it came time to write papers. I think my writing has definitely progressed throughout the semester and I hope to receive an even better grade on my research paper. Constantly analyzing articles was extremely helpful for me this semester.  I found myself having to analyze articles in all of my other classes as well. This was one of my least favorite things to do because I was never good at it, but after practicing it over and over again throughout the course of the semester it began to get very easy for me.  I know that everything I learned in this class will help me succeed throughout the rest of life and I will be using everything I learned in the years that follow.

Thursday, May 7, 2015

Journal Entry #6


Raw Material by Jane Maher was about her life as a teacher in a women’s prison. She experience many difficulties teaching at the facility. Many women had their own struggles related to the crimes they had committed and the reason they are in prison. She had to figure out a way to teach the women without causing them to react in a negative way. She faced these challenges many times where some women had outbursts because of what they learned in their class that day. She wanted to teach the women in order for them to have successful lives after they left prison but it was difficult for her because of these challenges which might have cost the program being taken out of the facility.

Although she faced many challenges many of the women succeeded after they left the prison. Many of them were able to get jobs after graduating from the program and were free from prison. The program can be seen as a success because many women started a better life after prison. This program changed the lives of many women and gave them a brighter future. If it wasn’t for this program many of them could have ended up back in jail.

Journal Entry #8


 

               Slavery and human-trafficking has been an issue for years. There are many forms of slavery and although slavery ended many years ago, the government considers forced prostitution a form of slavery. Slaves are difficult to identify because they are hidden from the public and also are threatened not to go to the authorities by the person enslaving them. Slavery is no longer based on race, gender, ethnicity or age and it is everywhere. The current issue of slavery in the United States is a difficult one to tackle.

                Although the government is taking the right steps in trying to create laws they are not effective. Creating a law is not going to prevent these things from happening because people are still going to do these things with the hope of not getting caught by law enforcement. For example, drug dealers, they know what they are doing is wrong and selling drugs is illegal but that does not stop them from doing it. They sell drugs to make money the same way the traffickers sell people for sex, to get paid. The police and the community need to come together to identify victims of human-trafficking. Creating a law only helps prevent the issue so much, but first they need to find the victims and identify the traffickers. Getting more traffickers off of the streets is what will help prevent the issue.

Journal Entry #7



“The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthrone is a story about a philosopher, Aylmer and his young wife, Georgiana. Aylmer was so obsessed with his scientific studies and looked upon his wife for a new experiment. Georgiana was so beautiful despite the fact that a hideous scar haunted her face. Aylmer had decided his next experiment would be to remove the scar. The scar never raised any concerns for anyone before this and everybody thought she was beautiful whether she had a scar on her face or not. Aylmer does his experiment and ends up killing his beloved wife.

One of the many themes in “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthrone is imperfection. Imperfection is spoken of over and over again throughout the story. Aylmer can not see passed his wife’s ugly scar and believes that she would be even more beautiful without it. He wants her to be so perfect he tries to combine his love for science and his love for his wife. Little did he know, taking away the scar would kill her because the scar was part of her soul. Trying to create the perfect wife had actually killed his wife because there is no such thing as the perfect person.

Annotated Bibliography


Bayley, D., Perito, R., Police Corruption: What past scandals teach about current challenges. United States Institute of Peace. Retrieved from http://permanent.access.gpo.gov/gpo19349/SR%20294.pdf

 

            This article addresses police corruption as an international problem. The authors increase our knowledge on what exactly police corruption is and gives insight on what could possibly resolve the corruption issue. The authors suggest different strategies such as the triage and bootstraps. They explain that corruption is the abuse of an officer’s authority for their personal benefit rather than to benefit the public. Perjury, physical abuse, sexual misconduct, robbery and racial profiling are all examples of police misconduct. Not all types of corruption are for personal gain of an officer.

            This article will be beneficial to my research because it explains all the different definitions of police corruption. As many know, there are several definitions of police corruption, some narrow and some broad. The narrow definition of police corruption is when an officer abuses his/her power for their own personal gain. The broad definition is when an officer acts in any unlawful manner whether it is for their own personal gain or not. The broad definition of police corruption makes more sense because there would be many cases where something would not be considered corruption. For example, false arrest and the beating of suspects is considered police corruption under the broad definition because an officer acted unlawfully but did not use this for his/her personal gain. An example of the corruption under the narrow definition would be theft or robbery because the officer is benefited from his/her actions. As one can see, there are many different views on what is considered police corruption.
 
 
Dempsey, J.S., Forst, L.S., (2014), An Introduction to Policing, Delmar Cengage Learning. Seventh Edition, pg227-pg234.
            In this book, the authors, who are retired New York City Police Department captains, give readers some background information on policing. Focusing on police corruption only, they give detailed definitions of police corruption, the reasons for police corruption and the effects police corruption has on a community. The authors explain all the different types of corruption and past incidents of police corruption. Police corruption has been a controversial issue for decades.
            The authors explain how a police officer accepting any sort of gift begins corruption making it easier for them to begin eventually accepting bribes. Although it does not seem a huge deal to accept small gifts such as free coffee and sandwiches, this is where officers begin to think, “What else could I get for free?” They further explain how corrupted officers affect not only themselves, but their whole entire police department. The community begins to lose faith in the law enforcement officers whose job it is to protect them. The community will not want to cooperate with the police if they do not trust them. Without help from the community the police are at a loss when it comes to cases they may need help with solving. They no longer have cooperating witnesses to crime scenes or access to any outside information. This book will help my research by explaining the process of how officers become corrupt.
 
 
 
Glazer, S. (1995, November 24). Police corruption: Can brutality and other misconduct be rooted out? CQ Researcher, 5, 1041-1064. Retrieved from http://library.cqpress.com/
 
            This article addresses cities that have turned their focus on other police misconducts regarding recent incidents. Mark Fuhrman, a detective in the O.J. Simpson case was bragging about his beating of two suspects and used derogatory language in interviews aired on television. The article addresses the fact that past corruption was identified with bribery and that today it is more about brutality and abuse of criminals. The article lists reasons why corrupt officers are the way that they are but does not in any way support corruption.
            Most corruption included bribery, where officers would accept money from criminals so the cop would over look their illegal actions. It can be hard for cops not to become corrupt in this sense of bribery because they see these criminals walking around with millions of dollars. These criminals have more many than some officers which may anger them and cause them to accept the bribes they are given. It is almost impossible to think that not all officers are corrupted in this sense because who would not want all that money? Most of the time when officers do arrest these criminals, the courts set them free which again will anger the officer. This can cause officers to beat the criminal or take his money because he/she feels that is more punishment than what they receive in court. This article will benefit my research by comparing past corruption to current corruption and what triggers officers to act in a certain manner.
 
 
 
 
Rubin, J., Blankstein, A., Gold, S., (2011), Twenty Years after the beating of Rodney King, the LAPD is a changed operation. Los Angeles Times.
 
            In this article, the authors explain how the actions of four officers ruined the reputation of the Los Angeles Police Department tragically. George Holliday captured the beating of Rodney King by these four officers on camera. Back then, in 1991, it was rare for someone to own a camera and luckily Mr. Holliday had owned one and grabbed it at the right timing for the video played a central role in the case. The officers were still found not guilty which caused rioting for days and the death of about fifty people. The video tainted the LAPD and police departments throughout the world, and departments are coming up with solutions to fix their reputations.
            It was only four officers that were involved in the beating of Rodney King, and as one can see the video tainted the whole police department. Actions by one single officer can and will ruin a police department as a whole. The riots after the Rodney King beating show the resentment that the community had toward the police department. It probably took a while for the police department to build that relationship with its people again. Today, they are coming up with a new theory for police officers that, “Someone is always watching”. With all the recording devices today such as cameras, cell phones, etc., there may be a reduction in police corruption who must have in their minds at all times that they are always being watched and their unlawful actions will not go unnoticed. The Rodney King beating is a crucial element for my research because this case is like a poster child for police brutality in the United States.
 
 
 
 
 

 
 

Research Proposal



Police brutality and police corruption are controversial issues worldwide. There are always many different sides to a story, and some cases involving corruption or brutality make it hard for courts to make decisions. Not all police officers and departments are corrupt but when these incidents take place, they cause mistrust between the public and the police. One corrupt officer can influence the public's trust or mistrust in the whole department. These officers create a bad reputation for their departments and also for their fellow coworkers. Many people also have their own opinions to whether an officer has done their job or has just taken excessive force to another level. Police corruption and police brutality raises concerns in the public and causes them to doubt their local police departments whose job is to protect the community.

There are many different definitions and examples of police corruption. According to Herman Goldstein, John Dempsey quotes his definition of police corruption in his book, "Introduction to Policing", as "acts involving the misuse of authority by a police officer in a manner designed to produce personal gain for himself or for others" (Dempsey, 2014, pg 227). The definitions of police corruption vary but they are all similar in stating that an officer is corrupt when they are using their authority to receive a benefit for doing something. Police corruption is not only a present day issue, it has taken its toll on police departments for years.

             There are many incidents throughout the years that police departments have experienced some sort of corruption by an officer or a group of officers. For example in the 1980s and 1990s police departments in Miami, New York and New Orleans experienced corruption and officers in these cities were involved in drug dealing, robberies, batteries and murder and were later on charged.  The "Rampart" scandal was another case of police corruption. In February 2000, more than 70 officers in the Los Angeles Police Department were investigated for committing crimes or covering up beatings and shootings, planting evidence and committing perjury. Perjury is when officers lie under oath or give false evidence or testimony. As one can clearly see, police corruption takes place all over the place and has been going on for years which makes it a significant topic for many to understand. Dempsey quotes Lawrence W. Sherman, "For as long as there have been police, there has been police corruption" (Dempsey, 2014, pg 230).
               
            The issue of police corruption is so important because it effects so many communities and police departments. These types of cases are always in the newspaper because the media is so quick to attack police officers. Dempsey states, "For the past few decades, police misconduct has made headlines far too often" (Dempsey, 2014, 233). Because of all the media attention, officers who are not involved in the corruption are effected as well. Corruption also effects relationships between the police and the public creating mistrust between the two. A relationship between the public and the police is very important because the police sometimes need the help of the community to solve crimes and without their trust they are not going to get that help. Another problem is within officers themselves, rumors are created because of the lack of information that departments release. Officers then do not know who they can and can not trust.
 
Police corruption is an extreme issue causing many different problems for police departments and communities. It is an important topic to be discussed and has many cases that will show clear examples of corruption.


Literacy Analysis


Literacy Analysis


              During the period of slavery, slavery was not accompanied with education. In Frederick Douglass’ narrative “Learning to Read and Write”, he tells readers his journey in advancing in his literacy skills. He explains the different approaches he used to teach himself these skills while being a slave. Learning to read helped him understand what it truly meant to be a slave and made him angry and want to be free even more. He finally understood what was really going on around him because he was able to read the
newspaper and books on slavery. Frederick Douglass’ journey in advancing in his literacy skills changed his life dramatically by helping him understand the world around him.
            Frederick Douglass was a slave and because he was a slave he did not have the privilege to obtain an education like other children did. Douglass wanted and education desperately, an education that the educated children were unappreciative of. He had many different approaches throughout his journey. His mistress gave him the first step in teaching himself how to read, she taught him the alphabet, and from that point on he found multiple ways to advance in reading. Douglass knew that he was not supposed to be educated but for some reason he wanted to. He says, “The plan which I adopted, and the one by which I was most successful, was that of making friends of all the little white boys whom I met in the street” (Douglass, 1845, pg 1), which shows readers that he knows he would not be able to get an education elsewhere. Douglass turned to these “little white boys”, who were not aware of the privilege they were given, to teach him how to read. White people during this time did not appreciate the fact that they were given an education, and one can see how important it is to the blacks who could not receive this education. It did not matter to him that these “little white boys” may not have been the best readers themselves (they were only young boys), but he was so desperate to learn how to read that it did not matter to him.
              Once he succeeded in learning to read, he got his hands on a book titled, “The Columbian Orator”. This book obtained much dialogue between slaves and their masters. The dialogue in the book helps him understand what the slaveholders’ intentions and thoughts were, and this made him angry. Readers can see how his resentment for his enslavers grew from the following quote, “The more I read, the more I was led to abhor and detest my enslavers. I could regard them in no other light than a band of successful robbers, who had left their homes, and gone to Africa, and stolen us from our homes, and in a strange land reduced us to slavery” (Douglass, 1845, pg 2). Readers can see here that Douglass never actually resented his masters or understood their purpose in holding him in slavery. Now that Douglass was able to read and got his hands on a book he disliked his masters more than ever. He was no longer ignorant and was able to see his masters as horrible people the way he should have saw them in the first place. Not only did reading this book help Douglass understand but it also tortured him even more and he began to wish that he never learned to read. Reading opened up a new light for him that he was not able to see before and he did not like it one bit. Douglass says, “In moments of agony, I envied my fellow-slaves for their stupidity” (Douglass, 1845, pg 3). This shows how much of an impact reading had on his life and would have on other slaves’ lives as well. This thought tortured him and changed the way he was thinking, it made him want to learn more and more about slavery.
            Advancing in his literacy skills made Douglass very intelligent and a careful listener. He would listen to people speaking of “abolitionists” but he never knew what the word meant. He knew it was connected to some sort of freedom from slavery from the context that people used with the word. He started reading city papers and read about the North, who was praying for abolition of slavery. He encountered two men who encouraged him to escape to the North for being such a nice boy, but he knew not to act interested in their advice. He knew that white men encouraged slaves to escape so that they can be captured and these men are rewarded by the slaves’ master. Douglass was educated and not ignorant like other slaves at the time who would listen to these white strangers. If Douglass never learned to read and expand his knowledge of slavery he might have listened to these men and made his life even worse. He remembered the advice and began thinking of ways to run away. He knew that he was too young to make an immediate plan but he would try eventually. If Douglass never came across this encounter and read the paper about the North praying for abolition of slavery, he would have never known that there was a safe place for him to be free from slavery. As you can see, learning to read kept benefiting Douglass, he was no longer an ignorant slave, he was an intelligent one and being intelligent he was able to protect himself and expand his knowledge on the outside world.
         In “Conflicted Literacy: Frederick Douglass’s Critical Model” by Wendy Ryden, she explains the purpose of students writing literacy narratives to “establish a critical connection to writing” (Ryden, 2005, pg 4). She uses Frederick Douglass’s 1845 narrative as an example and shows how this narrative influenced minority and working class groups. These groups are supposed to realize the importance of their literacy skills and to learn a lesson from Douglass’s narrative because he fought so hard to acquire literacy. She turns to “The Teachers and Writers Guide to Frederick Douglass” edited by Wesley Brown to prove her point. She interprets Brown’s texts as a way for students to understand the privileges they are given which they sometimes disregard as a privilege. Ryden says, “students who take literacy for granted will read about a man who had to fight for it and, as a result, will be roused from their complacency regarding the written word and its power to uplift” (Ryden, 2005, pg 9). This shows how many people take literacy for granted including the “little white boys” that Douglass turned to in search of succeeding in reading. She explains all the different purposes that teachers have for teaching Douglass’s narrative to their students. Many teach them this narrative to show them the gift they were given and others believe it shows a sense of empowerment. Many of the readings she refers to believe that Douglass’s literacy skills were essential to his freedom. As stated earlier, Douglass never learned to read he might have never been a free man, or even could have been killed. His literacy was an important factor to his freedom because it made an ignorant slave a knowledgeable man. Many people believed that Douglass’ literacy skills helped him escape slavery, including Ryden, “There is no question that in this text Douglass does indeed configure literacy as essential to his idea of freedom, and certainly this construction warrants scrutiny” (Ryden, 2005, pg 9). This shows how most people interpret Douglass’s narrative in a way that literacy was essential in his escape from slavery. Douglass wanted people to know that literacy helped him escape slavery and teach a lesson to students that they should not take what they have for granted. Ryden does have other beliefs of the narrative such as, there is more behind the relationship of freedom and literacy that everyone is getting from the narrative. When Douglass began to feel tormented by his reading, he felt as if he would never escape slavery. Feeling as if he was going to be a slave forever gave him a “sense of disempowerment” (Ryden, 2005, pg 13), and reading did not seem to be a good thing for him at all. Although he felt this way, Ryden says, “Ironically, by his own account, it is this sense of disempowerment that ultimately leads him out of slavery” (Ryden, 2005, pg 13). One can see that although learning about slavery upset Douglass, it still helped him escape slavery. Ryden proves from her text that literacy was essential in Douglass’s escape from slavery to a better life.
                      In “Frederick Douglass” by Booker T. Washington, he gives a biography on Douglass’s life. In chapter three, he speaks of Douglass’s escape from slavery. Douglass created a plan to compromise with his master and be able to keep some of his earnings while still paying him three dollars a week. Douglass began to make more and more money and planned his escape date for September 3, 1838. Washington calls Douglass “ignorant” several times throughout this chapter because Douglass was not making the best decisions throughout his journey. He finally arrived in a safe New England town and met a friend named Nathan Johnson, who guided Douglass with advice on how to find a job to support himself and his new wife. Douglass went from job to job and accepted any task he was given the opportunity to take. On his free time, he studied and read everything he could get his hands on. Douglass’s education was very important to pursue a successful life, “
He saw from the first that his freedom could not be profitably used and protected without knowledge and the mental discipline that comes with the effort to acquire it” (Washington, 1907, pg 65). Here, one can see again, that even Douglass himself thanked his literacy skills for earning his freedom. Douglass believed himself that he could not have created his plan and went on his journey without the knowledge he gained from reading. Without educating himself on slavery, Douglass may have never tried to escape slavery. Everyone Douglass met in his new life recognized his intelligence. His intelligence came from his life as a slave and the following quote proves how influential the book mentioned in the primary text was on his life, “The Liberator and Mr. Garrison's words were as important to young Douglass and his intellectual development as was the Columbian Orator, which had inspired him while a slave in Baltimore” (Washington, 1907, pg 67). The Columbian Orator was the book Douglass read when he was young that angered him and showed him what it really meant to be a slave. Washington’s referral to this book shows the significance for it in Douglass’s life because it was what had inspired him to escape slavery. If he never learned to read, he would have never read this book and would have never been inspired to be a free man. No one at this time ever expected a colored man to have a public career. After working job to job, Douglass was finally given the opportunity at a public career, an anti-slavery convention that was called by William Lloyd Garrison. Douglass was asked to say a few words at one occasion and was embarrassed by his lack of confidence when giving his speech. As his speech went on he grew more and more confident and had the audience roaring. They loved him, and Washington referred to this speech as “one of the greatest speeches Mr. Douglass ever made” (Washington, 1907, pg 71). Douglass was such an intelligent man from learning to read at a young age and being a slave. It was such an accomplishment to be a colored man with a public career. Douglass educated himself and from the following quote, one can see how influential his education was on his life, “Only three years out of bondage, never having been at school, wholly self-taught and coming direct from hard toil to a platform, he had been invited to speak before an audience of proud and cultured New Englanders” (Washington, 1907, pg 71-72). One can see that Douglass’s primary knowledge came from him teaching himself because he did not have the privilege of a white man’s education. He teaching himself how to read and write gave him this great opportunity that was not expected for a colored man.
              One can see from the primary text and the two following sources, the significance that literacy had played in Frederick Douglass’s life. His literacy skills gave him a better life and made him become somebody that others can look up to. He did not want to be a slave for life, and his literacy skills inspired him to take this journey and end up living a better life. The previous texts prove how literacy skills changed Frederick Douglass’ life dramatically by helping him understand the world around him.


Works Cited

 

Douglass, F., 1845, Learning to Read and Write, pg 1-4. Retrieved from http://www.gibbsmagazine.com/learning%20to%20read.htm
 

Ryden, W., March 1, 2005, Conflicted Literacy: Frederick Douglass’s Critical Model, Journal of Basic Writing. Vol. 24 Issue 1, p4-23. 20p. Retrieved from http://web.b.ebscohost.com.ez.lib.jjay.cuny.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=ec14614e-b33c-4768-9572-d96029adb12c%40sessionmgr112&vid=1&hid=101

 

Washington, B. T., 1907, Frederick Douglass, Philadelphia ; London : G.W. Jacobs & company, Chapter 3-4, p54-82. Retrieved from http://onesearch.cuny.edu/primo_library/libweb/action/display.do?tabs=viewOnlineTab&gathStatTab=true&ct=display&fn=search&doc=dedupmrg5619936&indx=2&recIds=dedupmrg5619936&recIdxs=1&elementId=1&renderMode=poppedOut&displayMode=full&frbrVersion=&dscnt=0&onCampus=true&query=any%2Ccontains%2Cfrederick+douglass&scp.scps=scope%3A%28CUNY_BEPRESS%29%2Cscope%3A%28%22JJ%22%29%2Cscope%3A%28AL%29%2Cprimo_central_multiple_fe&tab=default_tab&dstmp=1426719772738&vl(62436054UI0)=any&search_scope=everything&queryTemp=frederick+douglass&group=GUEST&vl(freeText0)=frederick%20douglass&vid=jj&institution=JJ
 
 
 


Journal Entry #5



            The advertisement shows cigarettes being put into a gun like bullets. The ad is saying that smoking cigarettes is the same thing as taking a bullet to the head. Smoking cigarettes can kill a person the same way a gun can. The cigarettes are used as bullets in this advertisement because the bullets are the part of the gun that will kill a person. Without the bullets a gun is useless, so the ad wants people to understand how deadly cigarettes are by using them as the most deadly part of the gun. This is supposed to get the point across to smokers that they are killing themselves by smoking cigarettes. It also keeps non-smokers from ever lighting up a cigarette and damaging their bodies. Not everybody understands how harmful cigarettes are to the body but once they see the ad they will see how damaging cigarettes are. The main purpose of the ad is to make sure people never pick up a cigarette again and to keep them healthy. One never knows the damage they are doing to themselves until someone else can tell them. The ad shows people that smoking cigarettes kills you just as much as being shot by comparing them to the most deadly part of a gun, the bullet.
 
 

 


Reflection on "The Library Card"


 

            Richard Wright tells his story on the spark of interest he had obtained on a man named Menken. He became so interested in this man who was hated deeply by the people of the South. But he was not a Negro, and this really made Wright question why society hated him so much. He became interested on learning more about this Menken guy, so he thought up a plan of asking one of the men on the job for their library card so he could take out books on Menken from the library. At this time, colored people were not allowed to be taking out library books for themselves; they did not have the same privileges as white people did. Wright was taking a big risk by doing this and educating himself. Wright figured that in order to be educated just like the people around him he needed to read. He began feeling just like the white men that surrounded him because he had the same knowledge they had. He had to hide his intelligence from his coworkers because he was afraid that they might change behavior towards him. Little did they know he was becoming more and more intelligent. Wright expanding his knowledge helped him feel closer to people around him and understand more about what was going on. He continuously read different books. Reading helped him gain the knowledge about the society that he was determined to get. He was able to understand things that he didn’t understand before and that was either good for him or put him deep into bad thoughts.

Journal Entry #4


Writing my literacy narrative forced me to think about a time in my life that I did not see as very important at the time being. Throughout the process I began to realize how important that experience actually was for me in my life. This assignment was significant because it made me remember and be able to tell about an important time in my life. It was also significant in learning new ways to write. Receiving feedback from other students and also proof reading their work was a lot of help in writing a better literacy narrative. Not only did it help for this assignment but for future assignments. Receiving the feedback help generate new ideas and new styles of writing and also helped when it came time to edit and make new drafts of my literacy narrative. The purpose of my narrative was to inform the class on an important achievement in my life and an important person in my life who helped me achieve this goal. When you are writing it is important to have a purpose for yourself to be able to organize your paper well. Without a purpose, your paper will never get to the point and you won’t be able to structure it well. I learned from this literacy narrative that having a purpose helps structure your writing in an organized way. As a writer, it was rewarding to look back on a time in your life that you never really thought about and be reminded on how important it actually was to me to learn how to read and write. Everyone has a different story and it's a great feeling to share your own.

Literacy Narrative


Practice Makes Perfect

 

"Poppy can you please read me Jake the Tadpole?!" I begged as my grandfather sat in his room drawing.

"Again? I just read that to you yesterday." Poppy chuckled with a huge smile on his face.

I was about five years old and Poppy was the greatest man I knew. The best part of it all was he lived with me, he was just downstairs from me and I loved being able to see him every single day. He loved drawing and he was great at it. Poppy was very successful throughout his career. He had his own show called "Cartoon Tell-a-tales", he illustrated and wrote books, he put together children's games, everything he did fascinated me and I loved learning from him. Of course his career had ended years before I was born but he always kept everything around to show and give to his grandchildren. His favorite thing to do was draw, and wow, was he good at it. I would always sit in Poppy's room with him and draw, sometimes I would even take his tracing paper and trace over his drawings. He was always good with children and his whole life was dedicated to making things for children, television shows, books, games, you name it. One thing he taught me without even knowing it was that practice makes perfect. Practicing your literacy skills is the key to success.
Poppy had a number of books, most of them I could not recall to this day, but I do remember 'Jake the Tadpole' being my favorite. Poppy wrote and illustrated the books and I loved listening to him read them to me. You could tell he was proud of his work, who wouldn't be? Around this time was when I started reading and writing in school, which I never liked to do. I never liked to be taught anything unless it was by my Poppy because he was the smartest man I knew. Every day I had Poppy read to me and my favorite part was when he would turn the book around and let me see the drawings. Nothing fascinated me more than being read this book that was written by MY grandfather. He was the best and I loved spending time with him, whether he was reading to me, we were drawing or even sometimes writing little stories together. It did not feel like I was being forced to learn, but Poppy was teaching me new things every day. I didn't like going to school and learning because I was so shy growing up, I always loved my grandfather's company more. I felt like he was teaching me more and learning was more fun with him even if he didn't even know he was teaching me. That's just the way he was, he never meant to teach you a lesson but you always learned something new from him every day.
Poppy and I always had a great relationship, and this had gone on for years. No matter how old I was getting I always loved to spend time with him. Even after I had learned to read and write in school I knew Poppy was the reason I was so good at it. My teachers always told me I was a great writer, and they thought because I was so shy and never liked to speak out loud, all my thoughts came out on paper. My grades were always great and at


my parent/teacher conferences, my teachers always talked about how great my writing skills were. They were always concerned about how shy I was growing up because they never got to actually hear me read in class. They started to pull me aside while the class was divided into reading groups to hear me read aloud. They wanted to get an idea of where I was at with my reading. They would have me read a few pages from a book and then explain to them what it was about. The week after they would do the same, increasing my level each time and before they knew it I was at the highest level I could get to. As the years went on, the same thing happened. Every year everyone was evaluated on their reading. My reading level was always one of the highest in the class which always amazed my teachers. Little did they know, Poppy taught me everything I knew, he was the reason I was a great writer and reader.
Over the years, Poppy began to get very sick. He recovered from a heart attack and a stroke and he was unable to do a lot of the things he loved to do. I started reading his books on my own because he couldn't read them to me anymore. No matter how many times I read the books, they were always my favorite because my Poppy wrote them and what was cooler than that? As Poppy lay in his bed, I would still come down and do all the things we did together, except this time I was doing them by myself. I drew him pictures all the time and he would ask me to hang them on his wall. I loved writing him stories on his typewriter and read them to him afterwards to see what he thought, and he loved them. Nothing was better than hearing him say he loved my drawing and my stories.
Without even noticing it, I was practicing my reading and writing skills every single day and I was enjoying it. I found the fun in literacy that I never enjoyed while I was at school. Poppy pushed me to practice without him even knowing it. Reading and writing at home with Poppy seemed so much different than reading and writing at school. I hated learning at school but at home with Poppy it was a whole different experience. It was an enjoyable experience. Every single day was better than the last. Every time I wrote something new, or would draw something new, I always wanted it to be better than the last one to impress him. He was always showing me new things as long as he could.
More time passed and Poppy was spending more time in the hospital than at home. I missed him, and it just made me want to read his stories, write my own and make my own illustrations even more. He made me love to write my own stories and create my own images the way I wanted to see them. And before I knew it, Poppy had passed. I was so upset to have lost the most important person to me. Now who was going to teach me and help me get better at everything I do? Who was going to listen to my stories and hang up my drawings on their wall? Nobody's opinion was as important to me as Poppy's was. All the time we spent together, he teaching me and helping me get better. He made me love to read and write. He made me practice it over and over again, and it was never forced out of me, I truly loved to do it because Poppy always told me I was good at it. I always wanted to be as good as it as him which made me want to practice it over and over again.
As I started to get older, my reading preferences had changed. I enjoyed reading things I could relate to and my favorite series of books were “The Clique” by Lisi Harrison. These books were my favorite because every middle school kid could relate to them at the time. I was so interested in the plot of each book in the series, which consisted of a group of rich, mean girls doing things that one would expect rich, mean girls to do. I found myself reading these over two hundred page books in the matter of three or four days. Once I finished the number of books I had, I was upset to see it come to an end, when I realized there was still books left in the series! Every Christmas or birthday or even just an outing to the mall, my mom would buy me the next book in the series. It always killed me to have to wait so long to read the next book, I was so anxious to see what would happen next. I then realized how fast I was reading these books; there were times when I would finish them in the matter of one day.
By the time I finished the series, I was too busy reading the books that were assigned to me in school to notice. Some books I enjoyed, others not so much. One thing I did realize, was that when it came time to read aloud in class, not everyone read as well as I thought they would. You could tell who did a lot of reading and who didn’t, and this also helped me become good at analyzing my reading. Many people read things and forget what they read, and this happens to everyone including myself, but I did find that I could understand everything I read. I never thought I would ever have to analyze my reading later on in life when they began to make us do it in high school, but when it came time to it, it was easy for me.
I never realized how important it would be for my future to be a good reader and writer. Looking back at the experience, having literacy skills is going to be important for my future. What makes the experience even more warming to me is that I shared it with such an important person to me. Poppy taught me everything, without all the practice I had I wouldn’t have become so developed in my literacy skills. I never even knew how much I was practicing something I disliked so much and I never noticed the benefit it had on me in school. I thank my beloved grandfather for teaching me everything he knew and encouraging me to practice something that would benefit me for the rest of my life.