Wednesday, May 20, 2015

Final Research Paper


Police brutality and police corruption are controversial issues worldwide. There are always many different sides to a story, and some cases involving corruption or brutality make it hard for courts to make decisions. Not all police officers and departments are corrupt but when these incidents take place, they cause mistrust between the public and the police. One corrupt officer can influence the public's trust or mistrust in the whole department. These officers create a bad reputation for their departments and also for their fellow coworkers. Many people also have their own opinions to whether an officer has done their job or has just taken excessive force to another level. Police corruption and police brutality raise concerns in the public and cause the community to doubt their local police departments whose job is to protect the community.
There are many different definitions and examples of police corruption. According to Herman Goldstein, John Dempsey quotes his definition of police corruption in his book, "Introduction to Policing", as "acts involving the misuse of authority by a police officer in a manner designed to produce personal gain for himself or for others" (Dempsey, 2014, pg 227). The definitions of police corruption vary but they are all similar in stating that an officer is corrupt when he or she are using their authority to receive a benefit for doing something. Police corruption is not only a present day issue, it has taken its toll on police departments for years.
There are many incidents throughout the years that police departments have experienced some sort of corruption by an officer or a group of officers. For example in the 1980s and 1990s police departments in Miami, New York and New Orleans experienced corruption and officers in these cities were involved in drug dealing, robberies, batteries and murder and were later on charged.  The "Rampart" scandal was another case of police corruption. In February 2000, more than 70 officers in the Los Angeles Police Department were investigated for committing crimes or covering up beatings and shootings, planting evidence and committing perjury (Dempsey, 2014, p. 230).
Perjury is when officers lie under oath or give false evidence or testimony. As one can clearly see, police corruption takes place all over the place and has been going on for years which makes it a significant topic for many to understand. Dempsey quotes Lawrence W. Sherman, "For as long as there have been police, there has been police corruption" (Dempsey, 2014, pg 230). As one can see from the previous quote, police corruption has been in effect for many years, and is still ongoing. There does not seem to have been many successful efforts made on solving the issue since police have been around protecting communities.
Cases involving police corruption are always in the newspaper because the media is so quick to attack police officers. Dempsey states, "For the past few decades, police misconduct has made headlines far too often" (Dempsey, 2014, 233). Because of all the media attention, officers who are not involved in the corruption are affected as well. The media influences the police as well as the public. The media portrays young African American men as criminals frequently. For example, when a young African American man grasps the media’s attention the media will portray him negatively, using photos related to gang violence or drug and alcohol use, instead of including a photo of him graduating from high school or serving in the military. This may have a major influence on the officer’s opinions and approaches to black Americans. This then causes the public to view their police departments negatively, believing that they are targeting the black community.
 Corruption also affects relationships between the police and the public creating mistrust between the two. A relationship between the public and the police is very important because the police sometimes need the help of the community to solve crimes and without their trust they are not going to get that help. Another problem is within officers themselves, rumors are created because of the lack of information that departments release. Officers then do not know who they can and can not trust.
Police corruption is an extreme issue causing many different problems for police departments and communities. It is an important topic to be discussed and has many cases that will show clear examples of corruption.
            Police corruption has been around since there have been police and there are many cases that prove the negative impact corruption has on the relationship between the police and the community. A significant historical incident that occurred in the year of 1991 was the Rodney King incident. The reason that this incident is so important in history and in my research on police corruption is because Rodney King is like the poster child for police corruption and symbolizes the racial tension that spread throughout America at the time. Rodney King was caught by the Los Angeles Police Department after a high-speed chase. After being caught, the police brutally beat King after pulling him out of his car. Little did the officers know, a man named George Holliday recorded the whole physical altercation on camera. The officers were charged with criminal offenses such as assault with a deadly weapon and excessive use of force by a police officer. Three months of trial took place and the officers were acquitted of all charges, which sparked the 1992 Los Angeles riots. The community started the 1992 Los Angeles riots against the police. As one can see, this incident weakened the relationship between the community and their police department. The community was clearly angered by this incident and felt that they needed to protest against these corrupted officers.
            As stated earlier, there are many definitions of police corruption. The Rodney King incident would fall under the definition by Herman Goldstein as, “acts involving the misuse of authority by a police officer in a manner designed to produce personal gain for himself of others” (Dempsey, 2014, p. 227). Although the officers in the Rodney King incident were not trying to benefit themselves in any way it is still a form of police corruption. The officers are abusing their authority in this case. The riots are a great example of how this form of corruption can have a negative impact on the relationship between the police and the community. The community was clearly rioting against the police for beating this man and walking free.
            There have been many attempts to solve the issue of police corruption to strengthen the relationship between police departments and their communities. Candidates for the police academy are much more educated and trained than they were years ago. Incidents such as the Rodney King beating, changed the way that these candidates and current police officers think of their jobs. Blankstein says, “Today, things are far different and the tape that so tainted the LAPD has a clear legacy in how officers think about their jobs. Police now work in a YouTube world in which cellphones double as cameras, news helicopters transmit close-up footage of unfolding police pursuits, and surveillance cameras capture arrests or shootings” (Blankstein, 2011). One can see the impact that the Rodney King beating had on future policing and that they must always act as if someone is watching them. When the public records the police it also creates a mistrust between the public and the police because now the police does not trust the community they are supposed to be protecting. When incidents are recorded they are most likely used against police. Blankstein says in his article, “The ubiquitous use of cameras by the public has helped serve as a deterrent to police abuse, said Geoff Alpert, a leading expert on police misconduct” (Blankstein, 2011). As one can see, the use of cameras are a nightmare to police officers. Cameras are also changing the way that police officers work and will hopefully have a positive effect on police misconduct. Sarah Glazer says, “In years past, corruption typically took the form of bribery, but today it's often brutality or extortion - with innocent citizens often the victims” (Glazer, 1995). Again another example of police corruption is from the O.J. Simpson case. Former detective, Mark Fuhrman, bragged on television about how he brutally beat two suspects in the case. He also used derogatory language in his interviews such as the “N-word” which enraged people all over America. Glazer says, “But his repeated use of “the N-word” was enough to give new credibility to long-standing complaints by citizens of police misconduct” (Glazer, 1995). His repetition of the “N-word” shows that he thought nothing wrong of the language and was extremely comfortable using it. Again people complained of his actions, which built a barrier between the police department and the people they are paid to protect.
            Incidents of police brutality and police corruption including more recent cases such as the Eric Garner case and the Michael Brown case sparked extreme disaster between the police and the black community mostly. A CBS news poll shows the extremely different racial views on the police. Fred Backus says, “While four in five whites say their local police make them feel mostly safe, that drops to 52 percent among blacks. Forty-three percent of African Americans say the local police make them feel mostly anxious” (Backus, 2014). Many people think that police officers tend to target minority groups which enflames the relationship between the police and these groups.
            Eric Garner was a forty-three year old man who had been arrested over thirty times prior to his final arrest for allegedly selling cigarettes on the street. He had several health issues such as asthma, diabetes and sleep apnea. Garner resisted arrest and Officer Pantaleo put him in a chokehold, which has been proven a deadly use of force from previous cases. Garner passed away after the incident. Again, just like the Rodney King beating the whole entire incident was caught on tape and the officer was not indicted for killing Eric Garner. Police are even more hesitant to trust their people and the people are still uncooperative with the police. Al Baker says, “On the streets of the city, from Tompkinsville to Times Square, many expressed their outrage with some of the last words Mr. Garner uttered before being wrestled to the ground: “This stops today,” people chanted. “I can’t breathe,” others shouted” (Baker, 2014). “This stops today” is referring to police using and abusing their authority and walking free when lives are being taken and families are falling apart. People do not want to support this kind of behavior by the people who are paid to protect them, therefore they are going to riot and bash the police as much as they can. This case has also created tension between police departments and their people.
            Michael Brown, an eighteen year old African American boy, was shot and killed by a police officer two days before he was expected to start college. There were two sides to the story, the police and the public. Again one can see the conflicting arguments that arise between the two, almost as if they are always going against each other. The public says Brown was surrendering with his hands in the air and the police say Brown attacked the police car and reached for the officer’s gun (Shoichet, 2014). The town of Ferguson went insane when Officer Wilson was not indicted. Larry Buchanan says, “The decision not to indict Mr. Wilson set off a wave of anger among those who had gathered outside the Ferguson Police Department. As the night wore on, the situation grew more intense. Buildings were set on fire, and looting was reported in several businesses” (Buchanan, 2014). One can see the extreme events that took place after the jury’s decision. Again, the relationship between the police and the public is extremely damaged and the people are acting out in extreme manners. The police are losing respect from the people when they are set free from charges of murder.
            After the multiple incidents such as the Eric Garner case, the Michael Brown case and even the Trayvon Martin case elected officials are looking for ways to stop police corruption. Police commissioner Bratton speaks of using body cameras on police officers while they are on duty, which will cause them to act in a different manner. When they realize they are being watched and anything that they do wrongfully will be recorded, they are more likely to work by the books. As stated earlier, police must have the mindset that they are always being watched. Others believe that officers need better training and better relations with the community. Andrew Peralta says in the Washington times, ““When you’re training’s all about shooting, handcuffing, the physical part — and not about the verbal part — it can create an imbalance,” he said. An officer also needs training on dealing with community members in nonthreatening ways and better communication skills, he said” (Swarts, 2015). This is a great start for officers to build their relationship with the community.
            As one can see, police corruption creates hostility between the police and the public. The police need the public’s cooperation in order to carry out their jobs successfully. If the corruption continues, there will be no respect for the police and no cooperation from the people. Without respect and cooperation leaves chaos and soon situations will begin to get worse. The police and the public need to work together in order to create a safe and orderly society.
References
Goodman, D., Baker, Al., (2014). “Wave of Protests After Grand Jury Doesn’t Indict Officer in Eric Garner Chokehold Case”. New York Times.
De Pinto, J., Dutton, S., Salvanto, A., Backus,F., (2014). “Michael Brown and Eric Garner: The Police, use of force and race”. CBS News.
Shoichet, C., (2014). “Missouri teen shot by police was two days away from starting college” CNN News.
Buchanan, L., (2014). “What happened in Ferguson?” New York Times
Swarts, P., (2015). “Police need better training and community relations, presidential task force is told”. Washington times.
Dempsey, J.S., Forst, L.S., (2014), An Introduction to Policing, Delmar Cengage Learning. Seventh Edition, pg227-pg234.

Rubin, J., Blankstein, A., Gold, S., (2011), Twenty Years after the beating of Rodney King, the LAPD is a changed operation. Los Angeles Times.

Glazer, S. (1995, November 24). Police corruption: Can brutality and other misconduct be rooted out? CQ Researcher, 5, 1041-1064. Retrieved from http://library.cqpress.com/

Bayley, D., Perito, R., Police Corruption: What past scandals teach about current challenges. United States Institute of Peace. Retrieved from http://permanent.access.gpo.gov/gpo19349/SR%20294.pdf

No comments:

Post a Comment